There are scientific reasons why Redline quiets an engine, esters and high moly. Only Motul has a similar formula in time tested oils. However, it is generally believed the Ester base in Redline is higher quality as proven by the way it holds viscosity at operating temps. The two brands are almost clones, but Redline is an American company and has slightly better numbers and best of all is cheaper, but definetly not cheap. You can't find a better oil to guard against shear or unwanted engine noises.
Royal Purple used to be one of the oil guys favorite, but since those days they changed the formula and it is less popular. However, they maintained that good formula and put it in their HPS oil, so they have good moly count and zinc in HPS, but not their otc stuff and neither of them have an ester based. If I was going to use RP, I would use their HPS.
But, I love their oil filters, I have tested them past 14 months and they still are like new. I now run them 2 years with my Redline oil change interval, but in those 2 years I only go 10k miles, I have tested this and still have 3tbn, so basically that means I could literally go another year on that oil, but to stay safe I keep it down to a 2 year oil change interval. The super oils pay for themselves because they combat acid much longer and do not shear off viscosity, so you can run them 2 to 3 times longer then their competition. There are other benefits as well, read the Syn thread in 4 gen if you want to learn more in oil. But if you use any paper filter even mopar, you literally should be changing your oil every 3k miles or 3 months. Synthetic filters are spun microglass, they simply do not degrade. Try running one for a year and cutting it open, see for yourself.
Penzoil synthetics have some good wear numbers as proven by used oil analysis's, PUP or PP seam to be good choices as well. That's my opinion for what it worth, but always double check info because one thing that always changes in oil formulations and technology.