Is Idling Really an Issue for Gas Engines?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

phoenixelijah

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2022
Posts
3
Reaction score
0
Location
NY
Ram Year
2020
Engine
Hemi 5.7
Because of the use-case for my truck I spend a lot of time in it, idling. I've seen mention that it's hard on the truck but have always done it as I need climate control and don't want to run down my batteries. Now all that said my 2020 Ram Rebel is the newest car I've ever owned and I don't know what's changed (if anything)

Does anybody else idle a lot? Like about 50% of the time it's being used

Open to opinions too - probably not a black and white question and I expect it's mostly anecdotal.
 

Rlaf75

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2015
Posts
1,495
Reaction score
1,516
Location
East Hartford CT
Ram Year
2011
Engine
Hemi 5.7
Idling for extended periods of time isn't really good for any vehicle. The hemi engines are notorious for eating cams and lifters due to extended idle times. It's called the "hemi tick". At full engine operating temp the oil is at its thinnest and at idle the oil pressure is at it's lowest.
 

crazykid1994

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2013
Posts
5,040
Reaction score
4,967
Location
Florida
Ram Year
2017
Engine
Hemi 5.7
There’s a small workaround. You can adjust your idle rpm up to increase oil pressure. Most guys are adjust it from the factory 600 which is supposed to keep your fuel usage at idle to a minimum up to between 650-750. Mine is adjusted to 650 and next tuning revision may push it to 700. My hot idle oil pressure is 38-40psi at 650 rpm. At 600 rpm my hot oil pressure would drop to 32-35 psi.
 

Highway

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2022
Posts
139
Reaction score
127
Location
Ky
Ram Year
2013
Engine
Hemi 5.7
There’s a small workaround. You can adjust your idle rpm up to increase oil pressure. Most guys are adjust it from the factory 600 which is supposed to keep your fuel usage at idle to a minimum up to between 650-750. Mine is adjusted to 650 and next tuning revision may push it to 700. My hot idle oil pressure is 38-40psi at 650 rpm. At 600 rpm my hot oil pressure would drop to 32-35 psi.
What is the procedure to adjust/raise the idle rpm ?
 

mikeru

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Posts
2,879
Reaction score
3,857
Location
The Palouse
Ram Year
2020 Limited
Engine
Hemi 5.7L
I'm not looking to get into an argument with @Rlaf75, or anyone else, and I don't disagree with him about idling in general. I just haven't seen any real proof that idling is what causes the cam/lifter issue on Hemi engines. There are also theories that MDS is the cause, or the design of how the cam gets insufficient lubrication, especially at lower rpm's. But like the idling theory, I haven't seen any real proof that any of those have been definitively shown to be the cause.
 

Phillyrube

Senior Member
Military
Joined
Jan 17, 2021
Posts
530
Reaction score
504
Location
Flatistan
Ram Year
2008
Engine
5.7
Police cars and taxis. Would I buy a used one? No. But then, I have seen police cars with 200k and no real issues. Part of my old agency had assigned cars, and those would be nicer than the pool issued cars, driven by multiple drivers. YMMV....
Heheheh.
 

Rlaf75

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2015
Posts
1,495
Reaction score
1,516
Location
East Hartford CT
Ram Year
2011
Engine
Hemi 5.7
I'm not looking to get into an argument with @Rlaf75, or anyone else, and I don't disagree with him about idling in general. I just haven't seen any real proof that idling is what causes the cam/lifter issue on Hemi engines. There are also theories that MDS is the cause, or the design of how the cam gets insufficient lubrication, especially at lower rpm's. But like the idling theory, I haven't seen any real proof that any of those have been definitively shown to be the cause.
It could very well be a combination of both idle time (low oil pressure, thin oil) and the mds system. I'm honestly surprised that with it being a common problem, we don't have any definitive answers as to the cause.
 

mikeru

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Posts
2,879
Reaction score
3,857
Location
The Palouse
Ram Year
2020 Limited
Engine
Hemi 5.7L
It could very well be a combination of both idle time (low oil pressure, thin oil) and the mds system. I'm honestly surprised that with it being a common problem, we don't have any definitive answers as to the cause.
It absolutely could be caused by that combination. Or it could be caused by something else. You aren't doing the engine any favors by idling excessively. But the point I was trying to make is that any evidence that idling causes cam/lifter failures on the Hemi are anecdotal. It's fun to speculate though :cheers:
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Posts
0
Reaction score
65
Location
Riverside California
Ram Year
2018 2wd
Engine
HEMI 5.7 Revolution 4.88s
It absolutely could be caused by that combination. Or it could be caused by something else. You aren't doing the engine any favors by idling excessively. But the point I was trying to make is that any evidence that idling causes cam/lifter failures on the Hemi are anecdotal. It's fun to speculate though :cheers:
I know Ram owners who don't idle and have had cam/lifter issues ... it's just a Hemi thing lol ...
 
OP
OP
P

phoenixelijah

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2022
Posts
3
Reaction score
0
Location
NY
Ram Year
2020
Engine
Hemi 5.7
I'm not looking to get into an argument with @Rlaf75, or anyone else, and I don't disagree with him about idling in general. I just haven't seen any real proof that idling is what causes the cam/lifter issue on Hemi engines. There are also theories that MDS is the cause, or the design of how the cam gets insufficient lubrication, especially at lower rpm's. But like the idling theory, I haven't seen any real proof that any of those have been definitively shown to be the cause.
pretty sure this is what I had seen that got me wondering
 
OP
OP
P

phoenixelijah

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2022
Posts
3
Reaction score
0
Location
NY
Ram Year
2020
Engine
Hemi 5.7
With the price of gas these days I don’t see why anyone would leave their vehicle idling.
I live in an environment that needs moderation of temperature and spend a significant amount of time waiting to travel, in the vehicle
 

JHoward

Senior Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2021
Posts
680
Reaction score
1,689
Location
NW, Louisiana
Ram Year
2017
Engine
5.7 Liter
My 2017 HEMI has a lot of idle time and idles ~ 600 rpm, however at hot idle the oil psi is ~ 48-49 so maybe that's the reason it hasn't imploded? ... or maybe it doesn't have enough miles on it yet? ... or maybe I got a good one? ...I don't know.

I don't really put to much in stock with what the trucks "internal smartness" displays. I'm going to keep up the oci's and keep the tank full and hopefully it'll keep on hamm'rn on down the road.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20221031_160830960.jpg
    IMG_20221031_160830960.jpg
    103.4 KB · Views: 17
  • IMG_20221007_121544219_HDR.jpg
    IMG_20221007_121544219_HDR.jpg
    147.2 KB · Views: 17

Elvira

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Posts
443
Reaction score
827
Location
Somewhere
The problem is not just because of idling nor is it because of pressure...the culprit with low idle speeds is the volume of oil. The amount of oil at idle speeds is what is detrimental to avoiding the "hemi tick". Oil pressure can be high but if you are not getting enough of it, that is where the problems start. Sure, idling is not good for any vehicle, but if you supply enough oil, you will stand a better chance of less harm to the engine.

 

1979PowerWagon360

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2019
Posts
309
Reaction score
392
Location
Central Florida
Ram Year
2022 TRX
Engine
6.2
This question brings lots of opinions. Pre-Eagle Head 5.7's had MDS and very rarely had the lifter/cam issue. So many agree it was not an MDS issue and something that began with the VVT engines beginning in '09. Yes the earlier 5.7's did occasionally drop a cylinder after extreme heat and then shutting them off but I digress.

How can anyone believe that extended idling does NOT contribute to the issue? Just the fact that it's more running time combined with more heat at idle alone contributes! Then take an engine that appears to be susceptible to the issue and add harmful idling hours.....

Anyone who works with a fleet of them that are subjected to high idle hours as I do knows the percentage that develop the problem is much higher than average. I cannot say whether it's a design flaw or what (oil slinger, oil passage design, etc.).

All this said I love the 5.7! I would say if you must idle for your work or whatever then you must, that simple. If you can avoid idle time then of course, avoid it. If yours does not have engine oil cooler as the Pursuits do, add one.
 

HEMIMANN

Senior Member
Supporting Member
Military
Joined
Dec 7, 2020
Posts
6,872
Reaction score
17,350
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Ram Year
2017 2500 Laramie Crew Cab
Engine
6.4L HEMI
Because of the use-case for my truck I spend a lot of time in it, idling. I've seen mention that it's hard on the truck but have always done it as I need climate control and don't want to run down my batteries. Now all that said my 2020 Ram Rebel is the newest car I've ever owned and I don't know what's changed (if anything)

Does anybody else idle a lot? Like about 50% of the time it's being used

Open to opinions too - probably not a black and white question and I expect it's mostly anecdotal.

For which gas engines? Your question presumes the design and quality of all gas engines are equal. Newsflash: they aren't.

Hemi Gen III engines have a poorly designed lubrication system that does not adequately lubricate valve lifter rollers under all conditions. OEM will not release any helpful information, even though they know all about the issue.

Members of this forum have done many experiments that have provided data showing extra dry lubricant additive statistically meaningfully reduces the audible noise associated with this poor lubrication.

Other factors known to affect lubricant supply to this component is low oil flow - notably, FCA put in a higher flowing oil pump in the performance variant of the engine. This speaks volumes to us, that idling Hemi Gen III adds risk to lifter roller and cam failure. Except for wasting fuel, money, emissions.

Check out solar trickle chargers - they've come way down in price.

We aren't aware of other engine architectures failing at the same rate this engine architecture does (5-10% per FCA Technician Dealership).

Other than this? As long as the engine is fuel-injected and computer-controlled with adequate oil supply, there is no real detriment to idling anymore, unlike the old carbureted mechanical days.
 

Wild one

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Posts
13,939
Reaction score
23,944
Ram Year
14 Sport
Engine
5.7
For which gas engines? Your question presumes the design and quality of all gas engines are equal. Newsflash: they aren't.

Hemi Gen III engines have a poorly designed lubrication system that does not adequately lubricate valve lifter rollers under all conditions. OEM will not release any helpful information, even though they know all about the issue.

Members of this forum have done many experiments that have provided data showing extra dry lubricant additive statistically meaningfully reduces the audible noise associated with this poor lubrication.

Other factors known to affect lubricant supply to this component is low oil flow - notably, FCA put in a higher flowing oil pump in the performance variant of the engine. This speaks volumes to us, that idling Hemi Gen III adds risk to lifter roller and cam failure. Except for wasting fuel, money, emissions.

Check out solar trickle chargers - they've come way down in price.

We aren't aware of other engine architectures failing at the same rate this engine architecture does (5-10% per FCA Technician Dealership).

Other than this? As long as the engine is fuel-injected and computer-controlled with adequate oil supply, there is no real detriment to idling anymore, unlike the old carbureted mechanical days.
I think the primary reason the 6.4's and 6.2's get a higher volume pump is more to do with the fact they use piston oil squirters to help keep piston crown temps down,offsetting detonation.With a bigger internal leak,you're going to need more oil pump volume to keep the bearings happy
 

DILLIGAF

Senior Member
Military
Joined
May 28, 2016
Posts
4,252
Reaction score
7,680
Location
Canada
Ram Year
2012
Engine
5.7
How can anyone believe that extended idling does NOT contribute to the issue?

Because there's literally no evidence that it does. One of the issue is the low RPM set at factory and is an super easy fix with HP Tuner.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
195,469
Posts
2,870,596
Members
156,177
Latest member
joeyoliver45
Top