If we're paying $4 a gallon gas and diesel is $5: when gas gets 8 mpg towing, and the diesel gets 10 mpg, we're paying the same per mile. Even if you go from 6 mpg towing to 10 mpg (gas vs. diesel) it's a .50 cent difference. Over a thousand miles that's $500, but if you add diesel's extra maintenance, oil, DEF, and price of admission - the line between them is about even...no?
Reading the lowest mpg here towing, IMO, the two are still even. Diesel can tow more and get +/- 20% more fuel efficiency. Gas offers lower cost daily, upfront $, and the easiness of a gas engine. They're even if you're not towing 15K+ loads. I asked a local with basically the same set-up as I got what he was getting towing 10K daily (heavy equipment), and he said "10."
Furthermore, I don't have nor have had a single high-performance car I drive that gets over 15 mpg with premium - most are 9-12 mpg. Sure, if I drove them slowly and with care, I could get into the twenties on the highway, but it's just not happening. I view an HD truck the same - they're not meant for fuel economy.
*ABSTACT*
If diesel were $2.5 a gallon, parts were available, no shortages, low upfront problems, and no possible diesel fuel shortages - then it would be a no brainer to go with diesel. My question is, when the 'real shortages' start happening, what will citizens do when diesel parts, oil, and fuel only goes to trucks for transporting goods? This is plausible, and even if we start manufacturing oil to fuel again in the US, it will take years to stabilize from where we're at. It's a reality - not a political statement. Truth is, I really wanted a diesel, but not in this economy. In the end, I needed reliability, parts, and fuel more than the extra "umph" right now.
@OC455 Did you not get 14 to the gallon? A little more than an 1/4 tank is 10 gallons? 10 gallons @ 14 = 140 and you got 145 total. Considering the terrain your DRW truck did well. Also, thanks so much, for telling/helping me to get the 35 over the 25.