I'm guessing you've never experienced the thickness of the factory ZF fluid,water is damn near thicker then the factory fluid.I highly doubt there'd be a measurable differance in the milege by dropping the fluid temperature 5 to 10 degrees.But there's probably a measurable differance in the life of the transmission. Point being the HD trucks with the 8 speed hardly ever get over 170F while towing 7,000+lbs,they seem to run more in the 165 to 168 range,while the 1500's will run on average 20 degrees hotter,so their must be a reason the HD's run cooler,and i'm guessing it has more to do with keeping the 8 speed alive. I know the PPE pan pulled close to 5 degrees out of my 8 speeds operating temp,so i would think this pan would do the same or more,and i couldn't see any change in the trucks milege,in fact i can't even see any measurable change in milege on a 500 mile trip,with the transmission running at 140 which is where it runs at now. Maybe over a 100,000 miles you might see a bit of milege differance,but i even wonder about that.On a cool day (30 to 40F) and a easy drive,my wifes 6.4/8 speed Challenger will take well over 70 miles to even crest 120F on transmission temp,and i can still pull down 31/32mpg with it,basically the same milege it'll get with the transmission at 170 to 180F. If you do any towing i think this pan or the PPE pan are good investments,just for the fact you have more fluid volumne to absorb contaminents and heat spikes. You should buy this pan and report back on whether you see a milege drop,as right now this is all speculation,and you could be the one to try out your speculations