And we're supposed to believe what you say why?
Why in the world would they design an engine in such a was as to be damaged at the time when it's working the hardest (towing or hauling)?
I agree with you that everyone should at least try to do their own research on things rather than believe what people say in a forum. But your first two sentences are doing exactly what you said not to believe.
Agree. This claim doesn't make any sense for a number of reasons besides the very point you're making.
The lifter receives oil in two ways: the internal hydraulic operation is oiled through the pushrod, and the lifter body is oiled by an oil gallery on the bottom side of the lifter. Oil flows to the lifter roller from oil pressure surrounding the lifter body in the lifter bore. Both occur irrespective of being in MDS or not in MDS.
NOTE: You can see a fairly good demo of this at [ gen 3 Hemi Lifter camshaft failure Uncle Tony ultimate battle finale - YouTube ]. The commentator unfortunately is long-winded appears to be in some sort of pi!!ing contest with someone else.
There are at least two randomness features involved in this problem. At least two surveys of owners reporting which cylinder's lifter caused camshaft lobe damage (I believe one was on this site). One [
The Fatal Flaw of the 5.7L Eagle Hemi V8 Engine Fully Explained (2009+ Lifters and Camshaft Failure) - YouTube] documented over 700 lifter failures and found that ALL cylinders reported lifter failures, MDS and non-MDS. The narrator states that in his survey the one cylinder that had the most failure reports was number 5, which is not even an MDS cylinder.
Then there's the one random issue that never seems to be addressed: why the vast majority of MDS engines DO NOT experience a lifter failure? And although there is no empirical evidence, the figure that gets the most attention is that these lifter failures occur in "five percent" of vehicles. If true, how are the other 95% of Hemis not experiencing the issue?
Of the several tech's that I've talked to, the only thing they are in agreement on is that Hemi lifter related issues have diminished considerably over the last year.
Regards,
Dusty
2019 Ram 1500 Billet Silver Laramie Quad Cab 2WD, 5.7 Hemi, 8HP75, 3.21 axle, 33 gallon fuel tank, factory dual exhaust, 18” wheels. Build date: 03 June 2018. Now at: 064560 miles.