I think you kind of answered your own question when you said said "running good quality 87" gas. I know its similar in some states like Florida (where I grew up) as it is in Canada and 87 is so touch-and-go depending on which station you hit. it seems like the bottom of a beer keg, some will be fine and others will you will feel. 89 and up seems that its a bit more consistent in its strength and quality just because it has a different filtering process.
So anecdotal evidence will depend on the quality and location of said gas, or if they used the same station each time or just filled up wherever they were closest to. I much prefer running 91 on my Diablo 91 tune, also for the sheer fact that there is quite less ethanol in 91/93/94 than there is in 87.
I believe that there has to be a reason they say 87 is acceptable but 89 is recommended, even if it was just ONE case of a blown motor or internal damage or anything really. Its enough for me to watch what I put in.
Now.. I go back to watching semi's drifting