For a soft tonneau, I think that the Truxedo is the best, but IMHO, all soft covers are prone to a small amount of leaking. THat said, the Truxedo is a high quality cover and will last a long time if yo can handle a little but of dampness in the bed.
Yeah, I picked up the Pro X15 and while I’m happy with it, there is a little water that comes in around the tailgate. The gasket only covers the inside edge of the tailgate by like 1/4” or less, so there’s not a ton of coverage there. Maybe try to find a longer piece of gasket rubber in the Spring when it warms up again.
I've had my Access Cover for over 6 years and still love it. AutoAnything is having a big sale on all the covers they carry right now, so if anyone is on the fence based on price, now is the time!
I had an Access Vanish on my last truck (Nissan Titan) and I liked it well enough, but it seems like it let in more moisture than my X15 thus far (it feels like, anyways), but I probably would have rebought it if they had a Vanish model that showed as fitting my 2019 (they might have one now).
I DID have to call Access for a replacement top (which I was paying for) and man, did the customer service rep have a stick up her ass. I wasn’t looking for a freebie, I’d had it for several years by then, but she was copping some pretty strong ‘tude. Whatever, it showed up and fit, so... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯