With gas at $2.00 , I am having a hard time seeing what the fuss about gas mileage is? If you do the math, it's really not worth a 1500 if you have any chance of needing the capabilities of the 2500.
For example, even if you drive 20,000 miles a year, and get 15MPG on the 2500, that's 1,333 gallons of fuel. @ $2.50 per gallon even, that's $3,333 of fuel a year.
The same 1500, getting you 20 MPG, would use 1000 gallons of fuel, equating out to $2,500 a year in fuel costs. While not nothing, it's $70 a month.
Right now, I'm getting gas at a straight 1.99.. At those numbers, it's $54 a month.
Remember, this is at 20,000 miles a year. If you're driving 10K, it's $27 a month.
Yes, I know it is money, and it is not nothing, but these are 30 - 60K Trucks. Get what you need.
For the poster who hated the gas mileage, and traded down, how did you do that if you had to pay sales tax on the 2nd truck and take the hit on trade-in? How long until you get that back?