Chemecial guys silk shine applied with a brush. I used foam applicators before but the brush works better for the lugs on my MTs. No slinging at all, dry to touch. It's water based so even if you make the mistake of applying to heavy it cleans up easily.
If I'm in a hurry I use Maxima SC1 Clearcoat in an aerosol can. It's actually not marketed as a tire shine but it works very well for that, no slinging, and again if you over spray on wheels or paint it cleans up easily.
A big thing for me was dirt and dust sticking to tire shines. I've used quite a few and had that issue but with both CG silk shine and SC1 CC I've never had that issue. SC1 CC actually keeps the tires nice and clean for an extended period of time.