I know I might get beaten, but I prefer the Good Year Wrangler.
I drive ~75 miles highway every day and these tires roll up very smooth and quiet. they also dampen the ride. Because I drive highway, I always give them 2PSI more- I drive 42 PSI in the tires. The Wrangler are the only tires, where I do not have a way higher wear in the center of the profile. I also had them on the old truck and I got ~60K miles out of it. I am not a sporty driver- I roll down the highway with 70mph and cruise control. I do not step on the brakes very often and when I see, they slow up in front of me, I take the cruise off and let it roll out, till I have the same speed.
I'm getting with these tires 21mpg with my way of driving. which is also part tire related.
I had the Hankoock (don't know if it's spelled right) and I hated them. hard, loud and after 30000 miles, the center was bald. Also because I drive some ramps on the highway, the left front tire with Hankook looked like something was eating on it. I did not get more than 35k miles out of it- even though they had a 50K warranty. And they refused warranty, because the center of the profile was bald and they said, I drove with too much air. I also noticed 1mpg less fuel mileage with the Hankoock.
Like I said- with the Goodyear, I never had the problem. they're even quiet, when the profile is low.