Thought I would shed a little more light on the issue. After doing much of my own research and trips to both shops, I think the guy at shop #2 is correct that they did not scratch the wheels. They used an adapter that can not possibly touch the wheel, the whole reason I was sent there in the first place. Guy at shop 1 has become a real ****, keep in mind I have stayed very calm and only trying to explain the facts. He has really tried to explain some complete BS ways that they balanced the tires and gets pissed when I ask him to show how things can be done. He keeps trying to blame the other shop of course, but good for me they did not even pay shop 2 for the work, they simply asked for a favor. So shop 2 is pissed and willing to testify because they have the correct equipment and did this as a favor and shop 1 is trying to stick it to them. Shop 2 is the one that has been willing to help if I wanted to file a claim and locate someone to fix them. Repair shop says they cannot be fixed. Shop 1 will not file with there insurance and will no longer talk to me. Even after the shop supervisor asked me to come talk to him as I did, when he informed me they are not doing anything about it, he tells his owner that I came by and spent all morning there parked in there bay and would not leave. The a hole asked me to come by, then told me to pull in the bay even after I asked why it would only take up space, and was gone in 20 min. The owner calls a guy I work with and tells him not to send any of his fn friends to his shop again, but the ***** cant call me. Now my friend is getting irritated at me and wants me to drop it. I said sorry bro not gonna happen after this mess. So they have received the first letter and nothing, second will go out in a day or so; then file for court. I think I've gotta decent shot with there lack of cooperation and shop 2 willing to testify that the wheels were all at least 3.5 ounces out of balance when I arrived there and the adapter they used. Yes I did see the adapter before shop 2 did anything, I just did know how it worked. After talking to a couple of attorney's they don't even think i need representation and say I have 2 years to file.