Ok so I'll be going with redline. I haven't really seen anything about changing the front diff...is it tet same process as the rear ???...and what do you guys recommend for a sealer??
There are two different mindsets, on either side of the spectrum, on this. One is the "always remove the cover and clean it thoroughly" camp, the other is the "just use the drain plugs" camp. Some choose something in between, e.g., remove the cover the first time for a cleaning, but just use the drain plugs after that for future changes. Others alternate; remove cover, for the next time or few times use the drain plug, then remove cover again for thorough cleaning, and repeat.
I removed my cover the first time on the rear only, since mine has the LSD (typically a little more wear metal), and cleaned it decently. I used a Fel-Pro gasket for sealing it back up. I cannot recall, but I
think I may have used a little RTV on it as well. If you do use RTV, make sure its the stuff designed for gear oils. I have yet to run into a name-brand RTV that won't make a decent gasket, but some do not respond well to gear oil and will break down/let it through after some time.
From now on, I'll just be using the drain plug and fill plugs. Bar disaster, I do not plan on opening the rear or front differentials again for as long as I own the truck. (At least another 30k-40k, which for me is several years.)