I like the concept, but the execution just doesn’t fit in my opinion. If the cylinder was the size as, or even just a hair longer than, the original knob it would look much better. As it is, it looks like a cylinder was just glued to the end of the knob and sticks out way too far. I dig the creativity though.
I did not one that was a little nub like the oem one. Its actually nice having it stick out that far.