Catch Cans and the Hemi 5.7

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Curmudgeon

Senior Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2017
Posts
1,910
Reaction score
5,878
Location
York, Pennsylvania
Ram Year
2014 1500 Laramie 4x4 QC, 3.21 rear, 8-speed
Engine
5.7L Hemi
I get it, and you're right. That's why I started collecting what came out of my catch can right from the start, and what I collected seemed like quite a lot. So I know for a fact what I have kept from the throttle body, intake manifold, intake valves, combustion chamber. See post #2.
 

Wild one

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Posts
24,681
Reaction score
57,958
Ram Year
14 Sport
Engine
5.7
I almost installed one, but it came with some silvery metal "coil" all bundled inside that looked next door to machining debris, and there wasn't a chance on earth I was sticking that thing under my hood. I could just imagine stuff breaking loose and getting inside the engine.

Anyway, I've seen lots of pictures of "oil" caught, but I haven't seen too much discussion on "what the can doesn't catch". Seems like everyone implicitly thinks these things are 100% effective. Do they catch 90% of what would have otherwise been sent through the engine without a can? Or do they catch only 25%? etc. If it's 90+ percent, that's a good design. If it's 25%, why bother with it? Just another part to fail. (Note I'm not saying it IS 25%, I'm just asking ... what it actually is.)

The UPR from Nick above claims their particular design is much more effective than most others... so there we already have differences and guys running some designs aren't being as clean as they like to think they are.

I've been on the fence about this for years, truck is probably too old now to worry about it unfortunately.
Install one,run it for awhile,then remove the hoses from it and compare them,it'll peel your eyes open on how much cleaner the hose after the can is,then the hose before the can is. That silvery metal coil if you bought a good quality can is not "machining debris" as you call it,but is basically a good quality course steel wool,and it won't lose any fibres.If you bought a cheap ebay/teemu can it might be another story,but if you buy a UPR / Moroso / BT can you won't have to worry.
 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
If you can get the option for a bottom drain I highly recommend it. I just used it on the Moroso I installed recently about a few hundred miles ago. Got about a teaspoon's worth of crap I don't want going back into the intake I just cleaned. I really don't care about any other benefits.
 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
And I guess a FYI for anyone reading this thread and deciding on a Moroso with a 4th gen mounting kit, the instructions show a bolt that didn't work so well on my '21 classic warlock because the lines run a little different. But there's lots of bolts to use and this one I used the bracket fit in there perfectly. 7964.jpg

Instructions show using the bolt top right in that picture. Other option is to easily make your own bracket and customize it to fit anywhere. The clamp around the can is removable and can be used with anything else with 2 holes drilled into it.
 
Last edited:

Wild one

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Posts
24,681
Reaction score
57,958
Ram Year
14 Sport
Engine
5.7
And I guess a FYI for anyone reading this thread and deciding on a Moroso the instructions show a bolt that didn't work so well on my 21' classic warlock because the lines run a little different. But there's lots of bolts to use and this one I used the bracket fit in there perfectly. View attachment 589956

Instructions show using the bolt top right in that picture. Other option is to easily make your own bracket and customize it to fit anywhere. The clamp around the can is removable and can be used with anything else with 2 holes drilled into it.
You need to upgrade those fittings to the ones i showed you awhile ago Jason.That's the only real downside to the Moroso cans,the generic brass 90's suck,not only are they ugly,they don't flow all that well either.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5235.JPG
    IMG_5235.JPG
    172.1 KB · Views: 3

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
You need to upgrade those fittings to the ones i showed you awhile ago Jason.That's the only real downside to the Moroso cans,the generic brass 90's suck,not only are they ugly,they don't flow all that well either.
Yep, I'll have to get around to doing that. Thanks!
 

Curmudgeon

Senior Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2017
Posts
1,910
Reaction score
5,878
Location
York, Pennsylvania
Ram Year
2014 1500 Laramie 4x4 QC, 3.21 rear, 8-speed
Engine
5.7L Hemi
You need to upgrade those fittings to the ones i showed you awhile ago Jason.That's the only real downside to the Moroso cans,the generic brass 90's suck,not only are they ugly,they don't flow all that well either.
.
That looks awesome, but I possess neither the shop nor the skills to put something like that together, so my Moroso is stock. Can you post a link to the Temu page where I can find a set? :Big Laugh:
 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
.
That looks awesome, but I possess neither the shop nor the skills to put something like that together, so my Moroso is stock. Can you post a link to the Temu page where I can find a set? :Big Laugh:
There's two parts there. Looks like a 90 sweep swivel fitting to a male male adapter. I just have to get a couple of each ordered.
 

Curmudgeon

Senior Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2017
Posts
1,910
Reaction score
5,878
Location
York, Pennsylvania
Ram Year
2014 1500 Laramie 4x4 QC, 3.21 rear, 8-speed
Engine
5.7L Hemi
Mine are Performance World fittings,but they're basically the same as the Evil Energy fittings. Wouldn't surprise me if the same manufacture built both.
.
A reversal - P.W. only ships to Canada! Evil Energy it is.
Thanks for the links @jason1 ;)
 

ramffml

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2019
Posts
3,772
Reaction score
7,875
Location
ramforum
Ram Year
2019
Engine
hemi 5.7
Install one,run it for awhile,then remove the hoses from it and compare them,it'll peel your eyes open on how much cleaner the hose after the can is,then the hose before the can is. That silvery metal coil if you bought a good quality can is not "machining debris" as you call it,but is basically a good quality course steel wool,and it won't lose any fibres.If you bought a cheap ebay/teemu can it might be another story,but if you buy a UPR / Moroso / BT can you won't have to worry.

I had bought this guy:

For me the intent was to see if it would reduce engine ping. I might try a more expensive unit yet sometime. Most of my ping cleared up when I installed the 180 tstat and it runs cooler.
 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
I had bought this guy:

For me the intent was to see if it would reduce engine ping. I might try a more expensive unit yet sometime. Most of my ping cleared up when I installed the 180 tstat and it runs cooler.
Any ping from early detonation caused by the PCV system that a catch can may help prevent would most likely be inconsistent, random ports, and not very often.
 

ramffml

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2019
Posts
3,772
Reaction score
7,875
Location
ramforum
Ram Year
2019
Engine
hemi 5.7
Any ping from early detonation caused by the PCV system that a catch can may help prevent would most likely be inconsistent, random ports, and not very often.

Maybe, but there are anecdotal reports that it has helped, such as this guy:

 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
Maybe, but there are anecdotal reports that it has helped, such as this guy:


Possibly, as WOT is not your normal driving around scenario and absolutely why a catch can would be highly advantageous in racing and needs dumped quickly.
 

crazy jerry

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Posts
1,356
Reaction score
971
Location
WY
Ram Year
2016
Engine
6.4
i think people just see the 4oz of "goop" in a gatorade bottle but dont bother to put it all in perspective that it took 5k miles and 250 gallons of gas (20mpg) for that 4oz "goop" to accumulate.
we know the intake valves stay clean as theyre always being washed by the injecter so that argument doesnt hold up.
4oz "goop" in 250 gallons gas is 8000:1 ratio. for the 2stroke guys that put oil in their gas at say 40:1 which would probly barely knock the octane down one point. how could 8000:1 knock it down at all. it doesnt. so the octane argument doesnt hold up.
yes there is a oil film on the runner walls but never accumulates to anything more than a film. its not hurting anything. so any argument here just doesnt hold up either.
im not anti catch can. i just think its a solution in search of a problem that doesnt exist. when you break it all down its such a very small amount of "goop" over such a long stretch of miles and large amount of gas
 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
i think people just see the 4oz of "goop" in a gatorade bottle but dont bother to put it all in perspective that it took 5k miles and 250 gallons of gas (20mpg) for that 4oz "goop" to accumulate.
we know the intake valves stay clean as theyre always being washed by the injecter so that argument doesnt hold up.
4oz "goop" in 250 gallons gas is 8000:1 ratio. for the 2stroke guys that put oil in their gas at say 40:1 which would probly barely knock the octane down one point. how could 8000:1 knock it down at all. it doesnt. so the octane argument doesnt hold up.
yes there is a oil film on the runner walls but never accumulates to anything more than a film. its not hurting anything. so any argument here just doesnt hold up either.
im not anti catch can. i just think its a solution in search of a problem that doesnt exist. when you break it all down its such a very small amount of "goop" over such a long stretch of miles and large amount of gas
In normal driving the octane reduction should not be an issue. The random <1 reduction in octane level may hit a single random cylinder and if premium is used would most likely never be noticed. In an extended scenario of WOT with a higher compression engine that could change.

I did not read that entire thread linked to but noticed it talking about noticing the knock with WOT.
 

crazy jerry

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Posts
1,356
Reaction score
971
Location
WY
Ram Year
2016
Engine
6.4
In normal driving the octane reduction should not be an issue. The random <1 reduction in octane level may hit a single random cylinder and if premium is used would most likely never be noticed. In an extended scenario of WOT with a higher compression engine that could change.

I did not read that entire thread linked to but noticed it talking about noticing the knock with WOT.

.016oz oil in a gallon of gas doesnt change the octane at all. sorry for the bad news
 

jason1

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2024
Posts
186
Reaction score
424
Location
US
Ram Year
2021
Engine
Hemi
.016oz oil in a gallon of gas doesnt change the octane at all. sorry for the bad news
Did I dispute that? Not sure if you're trying to argue with me just to argue?

Edit to add and again repeat: there is potential to have random very small reductions in octane that normal driving should not notice. Racing and WOT is not normal driving.
 
Last edited:

jc56berg

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 1, 2026
Posts
311
Reaction score
759
Location
houston, TX
Ram Year
2020
Engine
5.7L Hemi
The "gunk" caught by an oil catch can on a Chrysler/RAM Hemi engine (such as the 5.7L, 6.4L, or 6.2L Hellcat) is a highly corrosive, toxic chemical cocktail. Because Hemi engines operate with relatively high compression and feature short piston skirts with fewer rings, they are notorious for producing a significant amount of crankcase blow-by


A typical sample drained from a Hemi catch can contains a mix of the following chemicals and compounds:



1. Water Vapor and Condensed Moisture (~70%)
The largest component by volume, especially in colder weather, is dihydrogen monoxide (H₂O). Water is a natural byproduct of the hydrocarbon combustion process. When the engine cools down or runs before reaching full operating temperature, this moisture condenses in the crankcase instead of burning off.




2. Unburnt Fuel (Gasoline) (~23%)
During the compression and power strokes, raw hydrocarbons (gasoline) are forced past the piston rings. This raw fuel contains various aromatic hydrocarbons like benzene, toluene, and xylenes. It is particularly heavy during cold starts when the engine runs in a "rich" fuel-enrichment mode.



3. Engine Oil Mist (~7%)
The rapid movement of the Hemi's crankshaft and rods whips the engine oil into a fine mist and froth. This vaporized lubricant contains

  • Base oils (heavy hydrocarbons/polyalphaolefins if using synthetic oil).

  • Zinc dialkyldithiophosphate (ZDDP) and other anti-wear additives.

  • Calcium or magnesium detergents.



    4. Highly Corrosive Acids
When the water vapor mixes with sulfur and nitrogen byproducts from combustion, it undergoes chemical reactions to form strong acids:


  • Sulfuric Acid (H₂SO₄): Formed from trace sulfur elements in the fuel.

  • Nitric Acid (HNO₃): Formed from nitrogen oxides (
    NOxcap N cap O sub x
    ) generated under the intense heat and pressure of the Hemi combustion chamber.



    5. Abrasive Particulate MatterSuspended inside the oily liquid are microscopic solid chemicals and elements:


    • Carbon / Soot particles: Amorphous carbon black from incomplete combustion.

    • Trace wear metals: Microscopic particles of iron, aluminum, and copper sheared from internal engine components.
Why This Matters for a Hemi
If you don't use a catch can, the Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) system bakes this acidic slime onto your intake manifold, throttle body, and valves. Furthermore, introducing these unburnt fuel vapors and oil mist back into the combustion chamber lowers the effective octane rating of your fuel. This triggers the Hemi's knock sensors, prompting the PCM (computer) to pull ignition timing, which directly robs your truck or car of horsepower.


Note: Because this liquid is highly acidic and contaminated with raw fuel, never pour it back into your engine oil fill neck. Always dispose of it safely with used engine oil
WOW!!! Excellent breakdown of what the can catches. And here I am treating the liquid as run of the mill crankcase fumes/mist :oops:. All kidding aside, good read Wild :burnout:
 

Forum statistics

Threads
213,354
Posts
3,092,143
Members
174,575
Latest member
DITRIO
Back
Top