Between just the two of those, its a tough call.
My favorite go to for an all terrain is the Hankook Dynapro ATM tires. Only negative thing about them is their weaker sidewall, so you shouldn't go rock climbing with them. But the price... got a set for $650 and change for the wife's 18" rims on her 2014 Grand Cherokee last month. I've had them before on past vehicles... they are fantastic in the snow and light mud.
The tires that came with my 2013 (bought certified used) are almost new, and are Wrangler HP tires. I am hoping they are terrible in the snow so that I can justify the cost for a set of ATs.