Old thread, but maybe OP will let us know how his tires are holding up?
Sure no problem...
I did end up getting the Toyo's and I have to say that I love them. Now, since the extra weight was mentioned, I did notice that they hurt my mileage a bit, but have the security of a great tire during PA winters is worth it in my eyes.
I actually run two sets of tires...(I got a great deal otherwise, I'd be perfectly happy running the Toyo's year round.) the Toyos during the winter and a set of Cooper HP Plus tires during the summer. I'm really pleased with that combo. The coopers are lighter and get better mileage but the Toyos are much better in snow. If I had to do it all over again, I would still purchase the Toyos, no regrets here at all.
Now, I will mention, that every time I see someone running the Cooper AT3's I ask them how they like em...haven't had one complaint yet, so I don't think you can lose going with either, but I am pleased with my choice!
Hope this helps...