I have the continental terraincontact HT, i just switched from Kumho CRUGEN HT51, and my brother-in-law has the Defenders. All three are great tires, and each fit a different budget. All three have good traction, are quiet, and last a while. That said I prefer the continentals, then the Michelin, then the Kumhos. The Kumhos rode the softest, and seemed to have the best winter traction (open tread, and also 3PkMS rates), but handled sloppier, and I lost a mpg or 2. The Michelin ride the stiffest of the three, but not by a lot, and they are also the most expensive. I do not tend to like All terrain tires as i feel they are usually very compromised compared to a highway tire. When i used to work in a tire shop we had customers complain about All-terrain tires all the time (noisy, gas mileage dropped, do not tend to last etc).