If it fits it should be fine, I've never really known Cat to have bad filters in their branded stuff.
Only problem I can think of is will it fit....
You can't install a really tall filter (At least on mine - 2008 truck with a 5.7) due to possible interference with part of the metal structure (Frame) directly beneath it.
A fat/larger diameter filter would probrably be fine as long as the oil filter's O-Ring pad it has is the correct size but a taller one might have issues, depending on how tall it is.
Also, you really don't want a honkin "Fat" filter either since it's kinda close to the block once installed.