If it was ticking in operation, then it's hemi tick. If not, it's just a loose roller. Or are you asking if that is the possible cause of most of these hemi ticks? Can't say not, can't say yes, as most of us aren't choosing to take apart the top end when we get ticks. Perhaps that is the next thing we with hemi ticks should be considering. I do see they say lifter failure, but not cam failure, which is what we are most worried about. I'm not sure that alone would eat a cam lob, I think the lifter has to have backward pressure to eat that lob like we see.