I need to read that thread again. Main takeaway from that plus a few YT discussions I watched a couple years ago where they dissected and compared common brands was RP was generally higher quality. The devil is always in the details.
Unfortunately I think the 20-820 is too long for 4x4. I’ve wasted money on a couple different filters over the years that never turned out to fit. Figures the one I have to use sucks lol.
I spent most of the day yesterday re-reading the oil filter thread... sort of like slow distillation -- 120+ pages of rabbit holes, ******* contests, comedic relief, re-asking the same questions... and a bit of gold here and there (sorry for mixing metaphors).
As great as that was, I want to summarize what I cared about here to save anyone else that work (unless you're a ****** that enjoys 120-page forum threads):
RP 20-500 is too long for 5th gens
RP 20-820 is reported to work for 5th gens
RP 10-48 is OEM replacement size
10-48 has "issues", but that is based on a Amsoil TSB for the EA15K50 which is the RP 10-48 equivalent (EAO11 is the 20-820 equivalent).
The TSB basically says the smaller filter + extra fine media could clog. I didn't read that it has, and I've seen many cut open at extended miles without any sign of clogging... The TSB also says it's not been reported by customers, just a risk. Also won't damange the engine, since it'd just force the bypass to open, though that is obviously not ideal.
It sounds to me like this would only be an issue for peple trying to get max range out of filters in a 10k+ mile OCI world. For me, I always change at 5k. That puts my mind at ease, even for the 10-48.
When I read "issues" with the 10-48 I imagined yet another en****tification where they messed with the media, bypass failed, etc. I found none of that. RP/Amsoil filters are still near the top. One interesting set of data showed Fram Ultraguard having top efficiency, but I swore off Fram years ago (their ultra/synthetic line is proven to be great many places, this is a personal bias).
So based on all that, I am going to try the 20-820 and if that's too much of a bear stick with the 10-48 and sleep like a baby at night. I thought I tried the 20-820 years ago when I first got the truck and couldn't get it to fit, but may not have tried hard enough or mixxed that up with the 20-500. Many report it works, so I'll give it a go again and be even happier with the extra filter area if I can get it, but not at all worried about the 10-48 or Amsoil EA15K50 if that's all I can find at 5k OCI.
YMMV.