Cam/Lifter Swap Lessons Learned

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

CunningStunt

Senior Member
Military
Joined
May 12, 2017
Posts
334
Reaction score
309
Location
Abbeville, AL
Ram Year
2014
Engine
5.7L Hemi 4X4 Crew White/Chrome
So, as many of you know I decided to pull the trigger on my 2014 Ram 1500 Bighorn 4x4 due to misfire code in cylinder 5 along with the lifter tick. Getting to the cam and lifters was the easy part. In some instances though, I was my own worst enemy (Thanks @Wildone for pointing this out) and shot myself in the foot along the way. I wanted to make a thread detailing issues I had along the way in the hopes that it would benefit other members that decide to tackle this job themselves.

Lesson#1: As daunting as the job may seem, it is not that difficult. I ran into a bunch of issues of which 75% were my own fault and if I write this post correctly, you should be able to avoid.

Lesson#2: Timing. It's important. Do not take shortcuts. I tried the zip tie method and actually ended up cocking the chain off of the rear tooth on the crank/oil pump sprocket. This made it sound like a diesel engine on my first startup. The oil pump housing was the only thing that kept the timing chain on the crank sprocket. It truly sounded like a tractor my first time putting back together. It drove ok...but was LOUD and sluggish. So, I ended up removing all the peripherals again (Fan/clutch, radiator, shutters, alternator, water pump, compressor, and then timing cover) and as many oil pan bolts as I could (I have 4wd), and prying the oil pan down enough to remove pickup tube bolt and removed the oil pump. I then set and verified timing (I replaced all timing set components but my chain and guide were damn near perfect @184k miles so this may not be necessary). Don't get me wrong, this is a huge pain in the Alpha Fife Fife, but it was worth it and shoulda been done in the first place.

Lesson#3: If you take your heads to a machine shop, make sure they tap the spark plug holes if they use that aluminum paint after cleaning. Mine were coated with that aluminum paint but they didn't tap the holes afterwards and I stripped 2 spark plug holes and had to send the heads back. I took extreme caution when installing them but the residual paint on the threads caused binding and started to strip the threads...

Lesson#4: THESE ARE INTERFERENCE ENGINES! When I was setting timing after timing components were all removed but the heads were on, I encountered resistance when trying to turn the crank to TDC using the crank sprocket timing mark (Supposed to be at approx. 5:45). Well, I wasn't thinking and kept putting weight on the crank trying to turn it until a minute later when I realized I may be hitting a valve since I was not moving the cam in phase with the crank (DUHH). So I turned the cam, then the crank moved and I went about my business setting timing.

Lesson#5: After getting everything back together, I cranked her and she wouldn't idle. She would run @ higher rpms but wouldn't stay running. So, I went to harbor freight (See Lesson#6) and bought a compression kit. I removed a spark plug from every cylinder and tested. Cylinder #3 had 0 compression. I instantly knew...I had bent a valve...So, off with the drivers side head and to the machine shop. They replaced the valve and tested and I picked it up same day.

Lesson#6: Harbor freight compression gages are hit and miss. I would sometimes get a reading and sometimes not...it was very confusing and frustrating. After I had the bent valve replaced, I got all kinds of engine codes and still couldn't idle, so I had started to go down the path of a bent valve on the passenger's side but decided to do another compression test with the HF kit. Well, all went well with the passenger's side, but the driver's side I had 0 compression on cylinder #5!!! I just had the heads reworked and fixed cylinder #3! So, I remove the driver's side head again (3rd time) and take to the machine shop to verify they are all seating correctly. The shop called me and said the vacuum test and water test were SAT and the valves were perfect...

Lesson#7: Do not rule out variables just because it "ran before you started the job". The U1424 code sent me on a hunt I never would have finished. What I ended up doing was removing the valve covers and rockers and reinstalling pushrods. Now this isn't 100% verified but the solution to all my problems appears to be one of 2 things. Either I put a pushrod in an oil gallery and/or My #3 fuel injector was bad (I found a bunch of fuel in the #3 cylinder intake port when removing the intake manifold to take the drivers head off). So, I removed rockers and rods again just for fun, and reinstalled and also put a new fuel injector in #3. She started right up!!! But overheated! Burp the radiator like any other car. Remove cap, crank engine, add fluid as room allows for at least 10 mins...I was 1.5 to 2 gallons low even though I filled and added till there was fluid coming out of the water pump bleed hole...

Lesson#8: Don't give up. I still have a front main oil seal that's leaking that Imma pay someone to fix cus it's relatively cheap, but if you got 100k on your truck and you LOVE it, doing this will give you another 100k miles. This is my forever truck, and I plan on swapping my dads 2015 cam and lifters cus @ 104k miles, he got the lifter tick...God Bless!
 

Wild one

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Posts
13,718
Reaction score
23,372
Ram Year
14 Sport
Engine
5.7
So, as many of you know I decided to pull the trigger on my 2014 Ram 1500 Bighorn 4x4 due to misfire code in cylinder 5 along with the lifter tick. Getting to the cam and lifters was the easy part. In some instances though, I was my own worst enemy (Thanks @Wildone for pointing this out) and shot myself in the foot along the way. I wanted to make a thread detailing issues I had along the way in the hopes that it would benefit other members that decide to tackle this job themselves.

Lesson#1: As daunting as the job may seem, it is not that difficult. I ran into a bunch of issues of which 75% were my own fault and if I write this post correctly, you should be able to avoid.

Lesson#2: Timing. It's important. Do not take shortcuts. I tried the zip tie method and actually ended up cocking the chain off of the rear tooth on the crank/oil pump sprocket. This made it sound like a diesel engine on my first startup. The oil pump housing was the only thing that kept the timing chain on the crank sprocket. It truly sounded like a tractor my first time putting back together. It drove ok...but was LOUD and sluggish. So, I ended up removing all the peripherals again (Fan/clutch, radiator, shutters, alternator, water pump, compressor, and then timing cover) and as many oil pan bolts as I could (I have 4wd), and prying the oil pan down enough to remove pickup tube bolt and removed the oil pump. I then set and verified timing (I replaced all timing set components but my chain and guide were damn near perfect @184k miles so this may not be necessary). Don't get me wrong, this is a huge pain in the Alpha Fife Fife, but it was worth it and shoulda been done in the first place.

Lesson#3: If you take your heads to a machine shop, make sure they tap the spark plug holes if they use that aluminum paint after cleaning. Mine were coated with that aluminum paint but they didn't tap the holes afterwards and I stripped 2 spark plug holes and had to send the heads back. I took extreme caution when installing them but the residual paint on the threads caused binding and started to strip the threads...

Lesson#4: THESE ARE INTERFERENCE ENGINES! When I was setting timing after timing components were all removed but the heads were on, I encountered resistance when trying to turn the crank to TDC using the crank sprocket timing mark (Supposed to be at approx. 5:45). Well, I wasn't thinking and kept putting weight on the crank trying to turn it until a minute later when I realized I may be hitting a valve since I was not moving the cam in phase with the crank (DUHH). So I turned the cam, then the crank moved and I went about my business setting timing.

Lesson#5: After getting everything back together, I cranked her and she wouldn't idle. She would run @ higher rpms but wouldn't stay running. So, I went to harbor freight (See Lesson#6) and bought a compression kit. I removed a spark plug from every cylinder and tested. Cylinder #3 had 0 compression. I instantly knew...I had bent a valve...So, off with the drivers side head and to the machine shop. They replaced the valve and tested and I picked it up same day.

Lesson#6: Harbor freight compression gages are hit and miss. I would sometimes get a reading and sometimes not...it was very confusing and frustrating. After I had the bent valve replaced, I got all kinds of engine codes and still couldn't idle, so I had started to go down the path of a bent valve on the passenger's side but decided to do another compression test with the HF kit. Well, all went well with the passenger's side, but the driver's side I had 0 compression on cylinder #5!!! I just had the heads reworked and fixed cylinder #3! So, I remove the driver's side head again (3rd time) and take to the machine shop to verify they are all seating correctly. The shop called me and said the vacuum test and water test were SAT and the valves were perfect...

Lesson#7: Do not rule out variables just because it "ran before you started the job". The U1424 code sent me on a hunt I never would have finished. What I ended up doing was removing the valve covers and rockers and reinstalling pushrods. Now this isn't 100% verified but the solution to all my problems appears to be one of 2 things. Either I put a pushrod in an oil gallery and/or My #3 fuel injector was bad (I found a bunch of fuel in the #3 cylinder intake port when removing the intake manifold to take the drivers head off). So, I removed rockers and rods again just for fun, and reinstalled and also put a new fuel injector in #3. She started right up!!! But overheated! Burp the radiator like any other car. Remove cap, crank engine, add fluid as room allows for at least 10 mins...I was 1.5 to 2 gallons low even though I filled and added till there was fluid coming out of the water pump bleed hole...

Lesson#8: Don't give up. I still have a front main oil seal that's leaking that Imma pay someone to fix cus it's relatively cheap, but if you got 100k on your truck and you LOVE it, doing this will give you another 100k miles. This is my forever truck, and I plan on swapping my dads 2015 cam and lifters cus @ 104k miles, he got the lifter tick...God Bless!
Well you should be able to do your Dads truck in your sleep,just razzing ya lad,lol.I'm glad you finally got it all sorted out and running again.One thing i learned along time ago,is slow down, as soon as you get in a hurry,thinking you got this,is when you'll have issues. Don't worry most of us have done the same thing at one point in time,just accept it as a lesson from the school of hard knocks,the teachers are a bitchh,but they usually make you learn things. ;)
 

EdGs

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2020
Posts
2,477
Reaction score
3,554
Location
FL
Ram Year
2015
Engine
Hemi 5.7L
Still scares the f*ck out of me.

I hope I never have to go through this, but sonner or later I might have to. I've been blessed with my truck, 151k miles so far, so I hope it is later. MUCH later.

At least I know where I can get the help and support I will need if life heads in that direction.
 

ctwalton15

Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2021
Posts
79
Reaction score
86
Location
Kansas
Ram Year
2009
Engine
Hemi 5.7
I do appreciate you making this thread and being honest about what occurred with your situation I know it's definitely going to help me. I've got my heads pulled off and taken to the machine shop and i'll have them back in a few weeks. I know some more things to be aware of because of this thread and again thank you for that.

I am replacing the oil pump, not excited to but figured I may as well, I do have some time to kill while the heads are at the shop so I can most likely get it changed before or at least lower the differential by the time I get the heads back. I do want to remove the pan when changing the pump cause I'd like to put a new gasket on the pan Can't remember if I need one or not but I would like to for I suppose "ease of mind". Hopefully I don't have any huge issues just need to take my time and make sure its done right.
 

gofishn

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2014
Posts
5,082
Reaction score
10,130
Location
Iowa
Ram Year
2022 Ram 1500 5th Gen, Big Horn, 4X4, Crew Cab, 6'4" Box
Engine
hemi 5.7L, 345 cu in
That right there, is why I like this Forum so darn much!
Not that he shared an experience, and Solution!, that will help countless unknown others, for years to come but the willingness to own up and give the rest of us laughs as we see ourselves or, far more likely, remember ourselves doing the same or worse.
 

James OBrien

Senior Member
Supporting Member
Military
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Posts
440
Reaction score
684
Location
St. Louis
Ram Year
2018
Engine
5.7 Hermi
Just noticed some folks replied here, thanks! Replace your oil pump, I put on a high volume Melling and it's awesome... Been running it for at least 20k miles now on my rebuild, 50-55 at idle and 70-75 running. Some say it's too high, works fine for me.
 

Wild one

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Posts
13,718
Reaction score
23,372
Ram Year
14 Sport
Engine
5.7
Just noticed some folks replied here, thanks! Replace your oil pump, I put on a high volume Melling and it's awesome... Been running it for at least 20k miles now on my rebuild, 50-55 at idle and 70-75 running. Some say it's too high, works fine for me.
What pressure are you seeing at 6000 rpm James.i'm curious on where the Melling pump tops out at,as i almost wonder if the Hellcat pump is over kill
 

crazykid1994

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2013
Posts
5,040
Reaction score
4,963
Location
Florida
Ram Year
2017
Engine
Hemi 5.7
What pressure are you seeing at 6000 rpm James.i'm curious on where the Melling pump tops out at,as i almost wonder if the Hellcat pump is over kill
I was leaning towards the melling pump myself for my cam swap. If I don’t put the lift on my truck this year, then I’m going to start ordering parts for the cam
 

Wild one

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Posts
13,718
Reaction score
23,372
Ram Year
14 Sport
Engine
5.7
Looks like I need to add a channel for oil pressure on my HP tuners! Here's a really bad quality vid of a WOT run when I was switching to Ryan for tuning, looks like it maxes out around 90. Same on older diablo logs I had. https://youtu.be/Ak6IRzm0_XM
That's more in line then the Hellcat pump,as guys are reporting 100+ psi with the Kitty pump,and that's a bit excessive with stock bearing clearances in my opinion.
 

Black1500Ram

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2021
Posts
432
Reaction score
642
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
Ram Year
2015
Engine
5.7 Hemi
So, as many of you know I decided to pull the trigger on my 2014 Ram 1500 Bighorn 4x4 due to misfire code in cylinder 5 along with the lifter tick. Getting to the cam and lifters was the easy part. In some instances though, I was my own worst enemy (Thanks @Wildone for pointing this out) and shot myself in the foot along the way. I wanted to make a thread detailing issues I had along the way in the hopes that it would benefit other members that decide to tackle this job themselves.

Lesson#1: As daunting as the job may seem, it is not that difficult. I ran into a bunch of issues of which 75% were my own fault and if I write this post correctly, you should be able to avoid.

Lesson#2: Timing. It's important. Do not take shortcuts. I tried the zip tie method and actually ended up cocking the chain off of the rear tooth on the crank/oil pump sprocket. This made it sound like a diesel engine on my first startup. The oil pump housing was the only thing that kept the timing chain on the crank sprocket. It truly sounded like a tractor my first time putting back together. It drove ok...but was LOUD and sluggish. So, I ended up removing all the peripherals again (Fan/clutch, radiator, shutters, alternator, water pump, compressor, and then timing cover) and as many oil pan bolts as I could (I have 4wd), and prying the oil pan down enough to remove pickup tube bolt and removed the oil pump. I then set and verified timing (I replaced all timing set components but my chain and guide were damn near perfect @184k miles so this may not be necessary). Don't get me wrong, this is a huge pain in the Alpha Fife Fife, but it was worth it and shoulda been done in the first place.

Lesson#3: If you take your heads to a machine shop, make sure they tap the spark plug holes if they use that aluminum paint after cleaning. Mine were coated with that aluminum paint but they didn't tap the holes afterwards and I stripped 2 spark plug holes and had to send the heads back. I took extreme caution when installing them but the residual paint on the threads caused binding and started to strip the threads...

Lesson#4: THESE ARE INTERFERENCE ENGINES! When I was setting timing after timing components were all removed but the heads were on, I encountered resistance when trying to turn the crank to TDC using the crank sprocket timing mark (Supposed to be at approx. 5:45). Well, I wasn't thinking and kept putting weight on the crank trying to turn it until a minute later when I realized I may be hitting a valve since I was not moving the cam in phase with the crank (DUHH). So I turned the cam, then the crank moved and I went about my business setting timing.

Lesson#5: After getting everything back together, I cranked her and she wouldn't idle. She would run @ higher rpms but wouldn't stay running. So, I went to harbor freight (See Lesson#6) and bought a compression kit. I removed a spark plug from every cylinder and tested. Cylinder #3 had 0 compression. I instantly knew...I had bent a valve...So, off with the drivers side head and to the machine shop. They replaced the valve and tested and I picked it up same day.

Lesson#6: Harbor freight compression gages are hit and miss. I would sometimes get a reading and sometimes not...it was very confusing and frustrating. After I had the bent valve replaced, I got all kinds of engine codes and still couldn't idle, so I had started to go down the path of a bent valve on the passenger's side but decided to do another compression test with the HF kit. Well, all went well with the passenger's side, but the driver's side I had 0 compression on cylinder #5!!! I just had the heads reworked and fixed cylinder #3! So, I remove the driver's side head again (3rd time) and take to the machine shop to verify they are all seating correctly. The shop called me and said the vacuum test and water test were SAT and the valves were perfect...

Lesson#7: Do not rule out variables just because it "ran before you started the job". The U1424 code sent me on a hunt I never would have finished. What I ended up doing was removing the valve covers and rockers and reinstalling pushrods. Now this isn't 100% verified but the solution to all my problems appears to be one of 2 things. Either I put a pushrod in an oil gallery and/or My #3 fuel injector was bad (I found a bunch of fuel in the #3 cylinder intake port when removing the intake manifold to take the drivers head off). So, I removed rockers and rods again just for fun, and reinstalled and also put a new fuel injector in #3. She started right up!!! But overheated! Burp the radiator like any other car. Remove cap, crank engine, add fluid as room allows for at least 10 mins...I was 1.5 to 2 gallons low even though I filled and added till there was fluid coming out of the water pump bleed hole...

Lesson#8: Don't give up. I still have a front main oil seal that's leaking that Imma pay someone to fix cus it's relatively cheap, but if you got 100k on your truck and you LOVE it, doing this will give you another 100k miles. This is my forever truck, and I plan on swapping my dads 2015 cam and lifters cus @ 104k miles, he got the lifter tick...God Bless!
I feel you after tackling this myself and somehow messing up my head gaskets (ashamed) honestly no idea how it happened other than mental fatigue.

I’m at 117k and hope this gives me another 200k. I don’t love this engine, like the truck and it does what I need for something that about to be paid off. So for me doesn’t make sense to sell it.

I added the hellcat pump but swapped the spring down to the 50psi one, so I’ll keep you guys posted what pressures I’m seeing once she’s up and running.

I’ll add some lessons learned in my thread too hopefully someone will benefit from it cause there were some things wildone recommended that I wouldn’t have been able to do the oil pump or timing chain without.
 
Last edited:

Mikewkw

Junior Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Posts
29
Reaction score
15
Ram Year
2011
Engine
5.7 HEMI
I feel you after tackling this myself and somehow messing up my head gaskets (ashamed) honestly no idea how it happened other than mental fatigue.

I’m at 117k and hope this gives me another 200k. I don’t love this engine, like the truck and it does what I need for something that about to be paid off. So for me doesn’t make sense to sell it.

I added the hellcat pump but swapped the spring down to the 50psi one, so I’ll keep you guys posted what pressures I’m seeing once she’s up and running.

I’ll add some lessons learned in my thread too hopefully someone will benefit from it cause there were some things wildone recommended that I wouldn’t have been able to do the oil pump or timing chain without.
What are you getting with the 50 psi spring?
 

Black1500Ram

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2021
Posts
432
Reaction score
642
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
Ram Year
2015
Engine
5.7 Hemi
What are you getting with the 50 psi spring?
Hot idle is around 43-45psi, highest so far 3k - 60psi 3.8k 65psi.

I plan to add a thermostatic oil cooler for my towing needs as I’m still reaching 240°+ (down from 265° with the mods I’ve done - listed in my thread)
 

atom13

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2018
Posts
374
Reaction score
243
Location
USA
Ram Year
Na
Engine
Na
At least you got it done.

I bought a 12 with 138k with oil leaking into coolant. Machine shop cleaned both heads and reassembled. Same problem. Bought a 19 E-torque engine, tore it apart to rebuild, ran great but reluctor ring was not compatible. Took it apart for the third time just to swap reluctor ring. After all this I some how didn't torque one set of rod bearings. Dropped pan and was lucky to not have any damage. Pulled all rod bearings to verify and install new oem rod bolts. After six months of ownership I'm finally able to drive her.
 

PartTimeHero

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2017
Posts
124
Reaction score
86
Location
Oklahoma
Ram Year
2014/ 2004
Engine
Hemi 5.7 x 2
Thank you. I am beginning the tear down of my 2014 Ram tomorrow because of a faulty lifter so I am doing the 6.4 cam swap, Hell Cat lifters, Pump, new springs, rods, etc. I am nervous and excited. I appreciate the write up.
 
Top