Thank you
@Burla @Wild one and
@Hemi395
After doing some budgeting and math, and research, I found a 7-quart pack of Mopar 8&9 Speed ATF (Lifeguard 8) on Amazon for $126 shipped. Considering that the PPE pan is $290 shipped, I will be a little over $400 for the transmission fluid change, so I can't afford to throw expensive ATF away just to "upgrade" it. I won't add any Lubegard to it per
@Burla's advice. Lifeguard 8 fluid is made by Shell, which means that the additive pack is made by Infineum. It doesn't get any better than that. I believe that the only boutique manufacturer that has access to Infineum additives is AMSOIL. That's one of the reasons why AMSOIL is currently putting around 200ppm of Moly in their oils, because it's Trimer Moly, the best there is. In fact, beyond 80ppm Trimer Moly improves very little, but past 200ppm the improvement plateaus. That's why PUP 0W-40 has ~240 ppm. Infineum is co-owned by ExxonMobil and Shell, and BP also has access to their additives and collaborated on the research. I read a research paper from Infineum about Trimer Moly. Red Line, unfortunately, doesn't have it, that's why the huge amounts of Dimer Moly in their oils.
As far as the transfer case (mine is BW44-44) I have found the perfect fluid for it: Delvac 1 ATF. It's TES 295 & TES 468 Approved & Certified. It doesn't get any better than this as it's a Group IV & V ATF that is shear-stable and passes some really stringent industry tests. I know we're all enthusiasts here, but this stuff is actually better than both AMSOIL and Red Line. The original fluid recommended for these transfer cases was Shell Spirax S2 A389 (sold in a pretty Mopar bottle). In fact, Mopar even listed it in their MSDS, which I found after I spent hours on end figuring out what's in the magical bottles. Here is the MSDS:
https://www.kwparts.com/media/1695/68049954ga_eng.pdf
TES 295 & TES 468 are above TES 389. Basically, TES 295 is currently Allison's go-to fluid spec for severe service and long drain interval, and Allison recommends using TES 295 in place of TES 389. I figured that in a transfer case shear stability (due to gears shearing the oil) and smooth clutch engagement is important. If it's good enough for busses and trucks, it should do well in the poor man's pickup truck, lol. I ordered a gallon of this stuff (you can only buy it by the gallon) from Amazon for $38. I also found the engineer that designed the specs for TES 389 and then TES 295, and he said that TES 295 is an improvement over TES 389 because it's designed to be shear-stable from the get-go, be used for long drain intervals under severe conditions, and prevent copper corrosion (electric transmissions and components). TES 389 is basically Dexron III - back when GM owned Allison they derived Dex III(H) from TES 389. Then TES 295 came along to supersede 389. TES 389 means mineral and synthetic blend, while TES 295 means full synthetic (no Group III base oils or viscosity improvers). A lot of GM/Chevy guys use this stuff in their transfer cases. You can in fact use any oil that has an official Allison certification (TES 295 or TES 389) in your BW44-44 or BW44-45 transfer case safely.
Here is a good BW44-44/45 fluid alternative (not as good as Delvac 1 ATF though):
https://starfire1.com/full-synthetic-atf.php - Starfire Full Synthetic Multi Vehicle ATF.
I'm a bit torn on the gear oil. At the top of the food chain, above Red Line and AMSOIL, Castrol Syntrax (European) gear oil is the best of the best. The Syntrax Long Life 75W-90 has several heavy-duty approvals, a pour point of -54C and a flash point of 235C. Then the Syntrax Limited Slip 75W-140 is similar, but also carries several ZF diff and axle approvals. It's expensive though. My second choice would be Valvoline Synthetic Gear Lube (it's actually better than Mobil 1). Are you guys using it, is it good? Mobil 1 gear lube is a weak sauce (low pour points, low flash points) because they don't want to compete with their own Delvac products. Unfortunately, Delvac 75W-140 is impossible to get in the US, and their 80W-140 is hard to get and a bit too thick for the RAM's rear diff. I like Valvoline because they actually meet Milspec (J2306) and that's good enough for me. I'm just curious if others have a good experience with it.
@Burla Lubegard is a consumer-facing additive manufacturer. You can't judge their additives like fully formulated oils/fluids. For example, when you see "Lubricating Oils/Used" on their MSDS, those oils will evaporate or burn off as soon as the operating temperature is reached. That's why it's also a bit of a gamble if you use their additives in significant quantities because you can end up short on the actual fluid. For example, I upgraded my oil filter to the larger one on the HEMI (PBL24651), so now I need 7.5 quarts to reach the full mark on the dipstick. Well, I put in 7 quarts of Mobil 1 0W-40 and 21~22 oz of Lubegard Bio-Tech. I never gave it a second thought and after I changed the oil my dad went with my mom on vacation to Florida with my truck. When he came back, a little over half a quart of oil was missing. Of course, the truck doesn't burn any oil. That was at ~2300 miles after the oil change. I topped off the oil by adding a little over half a quart. Now I'm at 6100 miles and I still don't need to add any oil. The engine is silky smooth and runs really well. That's how most Lubegard products work, but most people never realize it,. They are meant to only leave the additive behind. That's why Bio-Tech doesn't change the viscosity of the oil for example. Some of their additives like their Gear Supplement have like 30% PAO, I guess to compensate somewhat for that loss, because who rechecks their diff or transmission the next day after they fill it up and took a longer trip somewhere to heat it up?
Anyway, looking forward to your replies, especially on the gear oil. I'm looking to keep my truck for as long as possible and keep wear low. At the same time, I don't want to overspend on oil if I don't have to. I am not brand loyal, neither does it make me feel warm and fuzzy if I have all of the same brand name oil in my truck.
Finally, I want to bring this to your attention: both Red Line Oil and AMSOIL need to fix their recommendations on their websites and make them correctly, especially when it comes to transfer cases. For example, the correct oil for BW44-44/45 and BW48-11/12 is AMSOIL TORQUE DRIVE, not AMSOIL MULTI VEHICLE ATF. Oh, for the BW48-11/12
AMSOIL doesn't have a recommendation. If you put in certain vehicles, like the Hyundai Sonata 2021, their oil recommendations are completely wrong. For Red Line I cross referenced some Borg Warner cases used on the Kia Borego with full time 4x4 and got 75W80MTL as a recommendation. When checking the owner's manual, it clearly said Mobil Fluid LT. What Red Line should have recommended was Red Line D4 ATF. So be cautious and don't blindly follow what they recommend.