I looked at full reviews on Tire Rack. For my needs, good snow and wet traction, good braking, quiet, decent mileage. The top rated tire was Firestone Destination ATs. Close behind was the Yokohama Geolander ATs. The Yokohamas were about $40 per tire cheaper than the Firestones, and I'm really satisfied with them thus far. 8k miles. Everything they were touted for: wet, snow, dry traction, and quiet. Haven't had to stand on the brakes yet. Will probably stay with the Yokohamas and upgrade to 33" (285s) when this set wears out.